Thursday, February 21, 2013

Letter for The Vine

Below is a brief letter I wrote for the Presbytery of the James’ newsletter, The Vine.

I first heard about the YAV program in February of 2008, courtesy of Google. I had just gone back to school after taking a year off. The preceding year had featured a great deal of introspection and wrestling with my faith, and I was looking for something to do over the summer. Instead, I found YAV. I knew it was something I wanted to do, but wisely, decided to wait until I graduated in 2009. I waited several months, and, the following December, applied. In March, 2009 I went to the placement event, very excited about the Kenya site. I left the placement event having been selected to serve in Northern Ireland. This was, at the time, honestly, a slight (admittedly very slight) disappointment. As I wrote in a note on my selection request, I would have been happy with Northern Ireland, but I would have been ecstatic with Kenya.

Thankfully, God and the YAV Staff made the right choice for me. My year in Northern Ireland, from 2009-2010 was exactly where I needed to be at that time. My placements, a Presbyterian Church in Lisburn, and a non-sectarian Youth Center, actually located in that church’s basement, stretched and challenged me in all the right ways. I landed in Belfast incredibly nervous about working with youth—and I worked with the full range, from toddlers on Wednesday and Friday mornings to teens on Friday nights. I gave my first sermon, which was very sweetly tolerated, planned worship, made copies, got soundly beaten playing soccer with 16 to 18 year olds, watched as 13-14 year olds ran circles around me on the soccer pitch, and, finally, by the end of the year, managed to hold my own against 11 year olds. I came home at the end of the year excited to make the much shorter move from Charlottesville to Richmond to start classes at Union.

I would not trade that year in Northern Ireland for anything, but I kept feeling called to Kenya. Fortunately, I was blessed with the opportunity to follow that call, and am now back in the YAV program serving in Kenya with CWS Africa. My work is showing me a different aspect of mission and evangelism, as I seek to tell the stories of the communities with whom CWS works. I was asked to write about what this year means, but that is exceptionally difficult to do right now. There are times when I wouldn’t choose to be anywhere else. There are times when it is an enormous struggle, but I came here to grow, and growth is rarely easy. Thus far, this year has been an amazing opportunity to experience a different culture, participate in different ways of worshipping God, to eat the best fruit I have ever had, and to experience life in a way that is simply not possible anywhere else. Thus far, I have sought to say yes to everything I can, which has taken me to beautiful beaches on the Indian Ocean and majestic vistas over the Rift Valley, from rural villages, miles from the nearest paved road to some of the most densely populated urban areas in the world, and through three countries: Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda. As for what this year really means for me, it’s too soon to tell, but I suspect that when I look back on it, it will have been exactly where I needed to be.


Monday, February 4, 2013

West Pokot


We were staying in a guest house near the Kenya-Uganda border in West Pokot.  Normally, on field visits, we spend the nights in towns, as we did for three of four nights on this particular trip, but the sites we are visiting tomorrow are too remote, necessitating that we stay in a more remote area.

IMG_2201It was rustic, true.  There was no running water, which was no surprise, but thanks to solar panels hooked into several batteries, there was electricity for lights.  Overall, it was majestic.  The guesthouse sits on a ridge in the midst of the Rift Valley.  On one side is an easy slope down past a church and school to the village.  On the other, a much steeper drop presents views across miles of the valley floor, crossing the border into Uganda.  One member of our group started planning to have her wedding there.



After getting settled in, I went downstairs to the large common room, and joined on of my colleagues for chai.  After a few minutes, a man came up and introduced himself, and, after asking if he was interrupting anything (he wasn’t) asked if he could tell me a story (he could). 

“I am an alcoholic. This is my only problem”  He tells me that very few people will listen to him, or understand him because of his alcoholism.  (Just to be clear, the problem of understanding does not come from his speech—he is speaking clear English).  He tells me that he is an alcoholic because of his friends—that he has tried to leave alcohol, but failed.  He tells me that he wants to go back to school, but cannot leave his wife and daughters.  He asks me what he should do.

Crap.

Ever since his first words, I had been silently praying.  Praying that he only wanted to tell his story, that he wouldn’t actually expect anything from me beyond passive listening.  Knowing that was unlikely, I also prayed that God would give me something to say when he finally did ask.  And, I’m not too proud to admit, I was also praying that he would just stop and go away.

“Can you give me counsel?” he asks.

Fumbling through past experience, memories of Seminary Pastoral Care Classes and YAV orientation, I finally stall for time: “I am not a counselor.”

He persists.

I tell him “It sounds like you know what you need to do, but haven’t yet found the strength.”
He looks at me blankly.  Clearly, he wants more than limited affirmation.

I ask if he prays.


"My wife prays for me.” He answers. 

“But do you pray?”

“Yes, my wife prays for me.”

I try one more time, and get the same answer.

I give up.

He starts talking about his family.

He is married, and has two daughters, aged five and three.  His marriage was arranged—his family gave her family 30 cows, and they married.  He wants his daughters to be educated.  He does not want to sell them to warriors, not even for 50 cows each, but his brothers pressure him to.  He tells me that they had hoped he would have daughters so he could marry them off for a bride-price.

He tells me that the oldest in is nursery school, but that he already struggles to pay the fees.

He raises cattle, like many in the area, and is under constant threat from raiders.  On one side, they are threatened by the Karamoja, on the other by the Turkana.  A little over a month ago, the Kenyan government came in and took all their guns.  (That gun roundup actually postponed our trip—we were originally going to go in early December).  Now he worries that they won’t be able to defend themselves against the raiders.

“We will just see them being driven off in the distance.”

He tells me “I do not count my cows, because tomorrow they could belong to somebody else. I may think I own so many cows, but tomorrow, someone else will own them.  This is why I am an alcoholic, because I am frustrated.”

He is called away before he can again ask me for any help.

Very little makes me uncomfortable.  I like things to be a certain way when I have the power to make them so, but I recognize when I don’t have that power, and in those circumstances, can be very laid back.  I do, however, struggle when strangers ask me for help, because I just don’t feel like I can possibly know enough. 

This man spoke to me of struggling with alcohol and temptation to drink from friends.  He starts talking about wanting to go back to school, but not being sure about how.  These thoughts are not totally alien to me, I can relate to them, at least somewhat.

Then he started talking about raiders and cattle rustlers.  I was completely lost.  There is nothing in my experience, and barely anything in my imagination which can compare to that.  In the US, I have always been able to rely on the police.  In Nairobi, I live and work in one of the nicer, safer neighbourhoods, with regular police presence, and even private security protecting the compounds containing my apartment and office.  West Pokot, however, is not all that far from Baragoi, where 40 some police officers were killed in an ambush by cattle rustlers just a few months ago.  Clearly, this man cannot depend on government protection.

So far, I haven't even addressed the dynamics that have him talking to me, and not my older and wiser colleague sitting across the table.  And yes, based on body posture, etc.  it is clear that this man is talking to me, not us.  My colleague grew up not all that far from where this village, and would have been a far better person to consult, but he isn't white.

My skin color and presence in this particular guest house mark me as a foreign church or NGO worker.  Someone with education, money and influence.  In reality, I have no influence, very little money, and my education is almost entirely irrelevant to this context.

The next day, my colleague brings up this conversation.  Chuckling, he tells me that I did not give that man what he wanted.  My colleague tells me that I should have told the man to talk to his pastor, but likely what he really wanted was money.

My colleague is probably correct, and I knew at the time that I should have tried to bring him into the conversation, but for whatever reason, despite thinking that in the moment, I failed to do so.

Now, back in Nairobi, it is far too late to try to offer better counsel, or try to gain deeper insight into this man's life.

All I can do his tell the story.

Thursday, January 17, 2013

KiSwahili and More

Hujambo. Jina langu ni Robert. Ninatoka America, jimbo la Virginia. Mimi ni mwanafunzi. Ninakaa Nairobi. Ninafanya kazi kwa CWS.

My name is Robert. I come from America, the state of Virginia. I am a student. I live in Nairobi. I work at CWS.

I've heard that it takes 10,000 hours to become an expert in something, about 300 hours to become fluent.

Our orientation here included 30 hours of formal Kiswahili instruction, enough for me to greet people, say a few simple autobiographical sentences, and hopefully do some minimal negotiation in the markets. I hope to put more time into learning this language, but I'll have to be self motivated--being a mzungu, most people in Nairobi will speak English to me. Even in the markets, negotiating in Kiswahili is not so much necessary as a tactic to get a better price.

The YAVs in Tanzania are having a different experience—most schools in Kenya are English medium, but most schools in Tanzania are KiSwahili medium—thus Tanzanians speak more, and subsequently better Kiswahili.  Tanzanians are also somewhat more formal—for example, in Kenya, to order chicken, one would say ‘Nipe Kuku’ (Give me chicken).  In Tanzania, that would be considered quite rude—one would instead say something to the effect of Please, may I have some chicken.  In many cases, one can simply use the more formal or polite option everywhere, however we have been told that if you use the more formal option in Kenya, people will think that you don’t intend to pay.

The combination of having the Tanzania YAVs in Nairobi over Christmas, visiting a few markets, and my parents coming, has drawn my attention to how will I’ve done at maintaining my Kiswahili.  I haven’t done as well as I had hoped, but, honestly, I’m finding that I’ve held onto more of it than I expected.  On a day to day basis, I don’t have much cause to use more than the salamas, or greetings—saying hello and good morning to the ascaris (security guards) at the apartment gate and at the gate into the office compound, perhaps a quick greeting to some of the people I pass on my commute.  In many areas of Kenya, one is still expected to greet each and every person you see, however, in Nairobi, as in every big city, people keep a bit more to themselves, and are likely to only greet people they know, though there is often some unspoken acknowledgement of others—often a sort of smile and head nod, though that might just be me.  When I am out in the field for work, however, people are much more engaging, and often we will stop the car to speak to someone walking along the road.

This level of engagement also held true in the more touristy areas which I visited with my parents, though my attempts at speaking Kiswahili were met with mixed reactions.  In some areas, particularly in Zanzibar (in Tanzania), people would just ignore my efforts and continue as if I had spoken English.  Some people, however, got excited that I spoke/understood some, and would mix in a little Kiswahili with their English. Others would simply switch completely into Kiswahili, and we’d both laugh once they realized that they had completely lost me.

Now, since I know many of you are really just here for the pictures, here are a few from the past month.

Ostrich Farm

Mom feeds a Giraffe

Dad kisses a Giraffe

Kilimanjaro

Elephant at Amboseli National Park

Zanzibar

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Christ is Born

Happy Christmas
Improvised Advent Wreath, photo by Rob Vaughan

Καὶ ὁ λόγος σὰρξἐγένετο καὶ ἐσκήνωσεν ἐν ἡμῖν, καὶ ἐθεασάμεθα τὴν δόξαν αὐτοῦ, δόξαν ὡς μονογενοῦς παρὰπατρός, πλήρης χάριτος καὶ ἀληθείας. (John 1:14, NA26)

The synoptic birth narratives are fine and well.  Bethlehem, the manger, the three kings/wisemen are nice details which provide fuel for pageants and songs.  They offer concrete answers to the five Ws (who, what, when, where, why).

John goes to a higher level.  

John takes us back to the beginning, before creation.  John gives us a single point of light in a dark and chaotic universe.  A light which is not overcome, but which brings order, grace, and truth.

A light which calls and empowers us to do the same.



Tuesday, December 4, 2012

The Holy Land

 



Photo by Rob VaughanLast Friday night, I spent a few hours dog-sitting for my site coordinator.  This presented me with a rare opportunity to watch TV (the TV in my apartment only gets on channel, and even that, only barely).  Being the news junkie that I am, I mostly switched back and forth between CNN and Al Jazeera English.  The Al Jazeera news ticker made one of the most interesting, and understated juxtapositions I’ve ever seen.  Two entries, listed back to back were:


-UN General Assembly overwhelmingly votes in favor of a diplomatic upgrade for Palestinian Authority to non-member observer state.       
-Israeli Government approves construction of 3,000  new settlement homes in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
(Note that the links are similar stories which I added Monday, not necessarily exactly what the ticker was referring to on Friday).
The ticker itself made no mention of any possible link between these two actions—and in the headline recap, the anchor’s only comment was something to the effect of it being ‘unclear’ if the settlement homes were approved before or after the UN vote.  Of course, it doesn’t really matter if the homes were approved before or after the UN vote.  The outcome of the UN vote really wasn’t a surprise to anyone.  The timing of Israel’s announcement is, however, a pretty clear signal: the UN Vote may be largely symbolic (it doesn’t directly change anything, however it may open some possibility of ICC action).
Now, you might think that I’m only citing Al Jazeera, an Arab news source. Voice of America, The Telegraph, and even The Jerusalem Post are reporting essentially the same thing, even making the linkage more explicit. Additionally, The Guardian adds that Israel is withholding $120 million in Palestinian tax revenue, though it does appear that the Palestinian Authority does owe Israeli utilities a great deal of money.
This past weekend, I also came across this article from the BBC about the comment from Mark Regev, spokesman for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that the UN vote will ‘hurt peace.’ Well, of course it will.  Israel will make certain that it does.  The Israeli government can say all it wants about desiring a two-state solution, but that is simply political theatre—the continued expansion of Israeli settlements, and the Israeli government’s tacit sanction of settler attacks on Palestinians and Palestinian land (here, here, here, and here) is a clear declaration that Israel will not permit the creation of a viable Palestinian state. 
The map below (as best I can tell, originally drawn in 2009 for Le Monde) is a stylized representation of the effect of Israeli settlements in the West Bank.  In this map, the water represents Israeli controlled regions, the warships are permanent check-points. The dark green zones are areas of only partial Palestinian autonomy.  For more analysis, go here.  Also, note that this map is from 2009.  Some of the islands will have shrunk in the past few years.

Map by  Julien Busac

For a less stylized, but more official look at the fragmentation of the West Bank, the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA) has a PowerPoint that covers the same information.  Slide 21 is especially relevant.
Coming back to the issue of violence: both sides are guilty, and both sides need to put down their weapons.  However, Israel is by far the stronger party, and Israel is the party which benefits most from the status quo.  The Jewish Virtual Library lists the casualty numbers in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict from 1920 to the present (as of this posting, not yet updated for October/November 2012), including Palestinian terrorism, Israeli government operations, and the several Arab/Israeli wars, but excluding Israeli settler violence.  Since 1920, total Israeli/Jewish deaths: 24,526.  Total Palestinian/Arab deaths: 90,785.  According to The Guardian, the recent violence added 5 Israeli deaths and 161 Palestinians. Clearly, Israel is holding the bigger stick, and ultimately, this situation can only be resolved by both sides, but in the short term, it’s absurd to demand the weaker party give up more.  This column, from Slate focuses on ways Israel is ‘insulting our intelligence’ and says a lot of things I agree with.  I’m not trying to say that Israel is more culpable than Hamas, Fatah, the Palestinian Authority, or any other group of Palestinians, however, I do think that Israel is in the better position to accomplish change.
For a model of this, look at the Northern Irish Conflict.  Hamas has more in common with the IRA/Sinn Fein than might be initially apparent, at least in the US. Most people in Northern Ireland see it sufficiently clearly that the Israel/Palestinian Conflict had been adopted as a sort of proxy conflict—with Irish Nationalists generally supporting the Palestinians, and pro-British Unionists largely supporting Israel.  The crucial difference is that in Northern Ireland, U.S. support largely fell on the the side of the IRA/Sinn Fein.  This US support served to level the playing field—it put pressure on the UK to come to the table, and, the threat of withdrawing that support gave the US leverage over the IRA.  In contrast, it seems that the only question in the US is over just how much support the US should offer Israel, and just how blind the US can be about the results of that support.  For more on parallels between the Northern Irish conflict and the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, see here, here, here and here.  Or just Google it—there is much, much more out there.
Right, so I’m done.  Tell me why I’m wrong in the comments below.